I tried every premium side dish at Cracker Barrel and ranked them from worst to best

From pancakes to loaded baked potatoes, I ordered all seven of the premium side dishes available at my local Cracker Barrel to see which one is best.

I tried every premium side dish at Cracker Barrel and ranked them from worst to best
7 plates of different side dishes at cracker barrel
There were seven premium sides available at my Cracker Barrel location.
  • In the name of research, I tried all seven premium sides available at my local Cracker Barrel.
  • Although I liked most of the "loaded" options, the loaded sweet potato was my favorite.
  • My least favorite, the loaded baked potato, was still delicious, it just wasn't quite as fun.

I'm not going to lie — I enjoy eating at Cracker Barrel. It serves reliable comfort food.

Over the years, I've come to especially appreciate the chain's sides. There are so many pairings to make your meal just what you'd like it to be.

Cracker Barrel's list of premium sides changes from time to time. I looked them up before going to my local restaurant, and what I found online was slightly different from the printed menu.

I ordered one of each of the premium sides available: loaded baked potato, loaded baked sweet potato, bacon mac and cheese, hash-brown casserole tots, loaded hash-brown casserole, loaded mashed potatoes, and pancakes.

Yes, it was a lot of potatoes. But they weren't all created equally.

Here's how the sides stacked up from worst to best.

7. Loaded baked potato
baled [otatoe with bacon bits, cheese, and sour cream on a plate at cracker barrel
The baked potato wasn't bad, there just wasn't anything very special about it.

A loaded baked potato is a pretty standard side, and I found this one to be, well, pretty standard.

When it was brought to my table, my server realized it wasn't "fully loaded," so they took it back to the kitchen to have sour cream added to the top. That turned out to be my favorite topping — it had a great flavor.

But in general, this was just a baked potato.

The chives, bacon, cheese, and sour cream made for a fine combination, but it didn't wow me the way the other sides on the list did.

6. Bacon mac and cheese
bowl of bacon mac and cheese at cracker barrel
I wasn't wowed by the flavors of the mac and cheese.

Though the base was goopy and cheesy (and frankly, delightful), the cheese flavor got lost a bit in the onslaught of bacon — which was, of course, also quite tasty.

If you're looking for bacon in every bite, this dish came with a generous portion of it. But if you're hoping to counterbalance the meaty flavor with some cheese, this might not be the way to go.

5. Loaded mashed potatoes
bowl of mashed potatoes with cheese, bacon bits, and green onion at cracker barrel
The green onions really made a difference in the flavor of the mashed potatoes.

The mashed potatoes were topped with colby cheese, bacon, and green onions.

Surprisingly, the green onions were the standout ingredient, competing with the bacon for the strongest flavor profile.

To that end, these aren't the kind of mashed potatoes that are going to act as a muted accompaniment to the meat and gravy on your plate. They're more of a standalone experience, but one that would certainly complement all sorts of main dishes.

4. Loaded hash-brown casserole
plate of loaded hashbrown casserole at cracker barrel
Cracker Barrel is known for its hash-brown casserole.

The loaded hash-brown casserole has a lot going for it.

Its base is delicious, crunchy (but still soft) grilled hash browns piled with colby cheese and bacon. I think my favorite thing here was the textural mashup of the crisp hash browns with the toppings.

With plenty of cheese and bacon, it shared some DNA with the other sides, but the texture set it apart.

3. Pancakes
two pancakes on a plate with a ball of butter on top at cracker barrel
I wasn't expecting to try the chain's pancakes.

Pancakes weren't listed as a premium side online, but they were on the menu in the restaurant, so of course, I went for it. And I'm glad I did.

The stack of two pancakes didn't come with syrup — I imagine I could've requested if I wanted — but that was just fine. They were buttery, crispy, and light.

Amid a table populated with a lot of potatoes smothered in bacon and cheese, they were a welcome break. Plus, they were just really delicious.

2. Hash-brown casserole tots
bowl of hashbrown casserole tots at cracker barrel
The tots were a surprisingly delicious side.

Full disclosure: My husband and I each stole a tot from the bowl before I snapped the photo of this one.

These tots were made out of Cracker Barrel's signature hash-brown casserole. It's a very simple concept, and I can't quite put my finger on why, but I just loved them.

I think they'd go well with any dish.

1. Loaded baked sweet potato
baked sweet potato with marshmallow, nuts, and cinnamon at cracker barrel
The sweet toppings on the baked sweet potato won me over.

My favorite side was a total surprise to me. The loaded baked sweet potato was the one I was most dubious of during my research — mostly because it sounded like it was going to be overwhelming.

But I thought it had a really good balance of sweet and salty. The sweet potato itself was a good foil to the very sweet marshmallow topping and butter-pecan sauce, and the candied pecans added some textural intrigue.

I couldn't stop coming back to this one, and a few days out from my dining experience, it's the one I've thought about the most.

It's definitely on the sweet side — almost more like a dessert. But hey, there's nothing wrong with that every now and then.

Read the original article on Business Insider

What's Your Reaction?

like

dislike

love

funny

angry

sad

wow